Short answer: New business owners usually combine three methods. Cost-plus pricing sets your floor: add up every cost per unit and add a markup so each sale makes a profit. Competitor-based pricing shows the range customers already accept. Value-based pricing sets your ceiling: what the result is worth to the customer. Pick a price between the floor and the ceiling that fits your positioning, test it with real buyers, and review it at least every few months as costs change.
Pricing is one of the few decisions that changes profit immediately without adding a single customer. It is also the one many new owners get wrong by guessing, copying a competitor or charging too little out of fear. This guide explains each method in plain terms, with worked examples for a product business and a service business.
Know your numbers before you pick a method
Every pricing method depends on knowing what it costs you to deliver one unit or one hour of work. Four terms matter:
- Variable costs rise with each sale: materials, packaging, shipping, payment processing fees, sales commissions.
- Fixed costs stay the same whatever you sell: rent, software, insurance, phone, your own salary target.
- Markup is profit as a percentage of cost. A $10 cost sold at $15 is a 50% markup.
- Gross margin is profit as a percentage of price. The same $15 sale has a 33% margin ($5 ÷ $15).
Mixing up markup and margin is a classic error. If you want a 50% margin on a $10 cost, the price is $20, not $15.
Also calculate your break-even point: how many sales cover your fixed costs. Formula: fixed costs ÷ (price minus variable cost per unit). If fixed costs are $2,000 a month and each sale contributes $10, you need 200 sales a month to break even.
Cost-plus pricing
Cost-plus pricing means adding a fixed markup to your total cost per unit. It is simple, defensible and guarantees each sale covers its costs, which is why it is the most common starting point.
Example: a candle maker
| Cost item (per candle) | Amount |
|---|---|
| Wax, wick, fragrance, jar | $4.20 |
| Label and box | $0.80 |
| Share of fixed costs ($900 a month ÷ 300 candles) | $3.00 |
| Total cost per candle | $8.00 |
| Price at 100% markup | $16.00 |
| Price at 150% markup | $20.00 |
Strengths: easy to calculate and explain; protects against selling at a loss. Weaknesses: ignores what customers will pay, so it can leave money on the table, and it depends on a sales forecast to spread fixed costs. If you sell 150 candles instead of 300, your real cost per candle jumps to $11.
Competitor-based pricing
Competitor-based pricing sets your price relative to similar offers customers can buy instead: at the market, slightly below or deliberately above. It is useful because buyers compare, and it tells you the range they already accept.
How to do it
- List five to ten real alternatives your customer would consider, including doing nothing or doing it themselves.
- Record their price, what is included, delivery time, guarantees and reviews.
- Decide where you sit: budget, mid-market or premium, and why.
Example: the same candle
Suppose comparable hand-poured candles at local shops and online sell for $18 to $32. A price of $16 would undercut the market and signal "cheaper", while $24 places you mid-market. If your scent range or packaging stands out, $28 may be realistic.
Strengths: grounded in what customers actually pay; quick to research. Weaknesses: competitors may have different costs or be pricing badly themselves, and copying them can start a race to the bottom. The SBA's market research guidance recommends studying competitors to understand where you fit, not to clone their prices.
Value-based pricing
Value-based pricing sets the price according to the value the customer receives: money saved, money earned, time saved, risk reduced or how much they care about the result. It often supports the highest prices, especially for services.
Example: a freelance bookkeeper
A bookkeeper's cost-plus price might be $45 an hour. But consider the client: a small business owner who spends 10 hours a month on books and values their own time at $100 an hour, and who once paid a $400 penalty for a late filing. Clean monthly books save them roughly $1,000 of time and reduce penalty risk. A monthly package at $450 to $600 is a clear win for the client, even though it may work out to well above $45 per hour of the bookkeeper's time.
How to find value
- Ask customers what problem they are solving and what it costs them today.
- Ask what they tried before and what they paid for it.
- Quantify outcomes where you can: hours saved, revenue added, errors avoided.
Strengths: captures more of the value you create; rewards expertise and results. Weaknesses: needs customer research and confidence to explain, and value differs between customers. Our guide on how to validate a business idea covers the customer interviews that feed this method.
The three methods compared
| Method | Starts from | Best for | Main risk |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost-plus | Your costs | Physical products, wholesale, early-stage businesses | Underpricing what customers would pay |
| Competitor-based | Market prices | Crowded markets where buyers compare easily | Copying others' mistakes; price wars |
| Value-based | Customer outcome | Services, B2B, specialist or premium products | Overestimating value without evidence |
In practice: use cost-plus to find your floor, competitors to see the market range and value to find your ceiling. Price between the floor and the ceiling.
Pricing a service: hourly, project or retainer
Service businesses have an extra choice: how to package the price.
- Hourly: simple and fair for unclear scopes, but it caps your income and punishes you for getting faster. Calculate a minimum rate: (target annual income + yearly business costs + taxes) ÷ realistic billable hours. Many solo workers can bill only 50% to 70% of their working hours once admin and sales are counted.
- Project or fixed fee: clients like knowing the total. Price from your estimated hours plus a buffer for scope risk, then check it against value.
- Retainer or subscription: a monthly fee for ongoing work. It smooths income, which helps if your earnings are irregular.
Worked minimum rate
Target income $60,000, business costs $6,000, and roughly $12,000 set aside for taxes, totalling $78,000. At 1,100 billable hours a year, the minimum rate is about $71 an hour. Quoting $45 because "that is what others charge" would mean working at a loss against your goals.
Common pricing mistakes new owners make
- Forgetting your own pay. If your salary is not in your costs, your profit is an illusion.
- Ignoring fees. Card processing, marketplace commissions and shipping add up quickly.
- Pricing too low to win customers. Low prices attract price-sensitive buyers and are hard to raise later.
- Discounting by default. Offer extras or payment terms before cutting price.
- Never reviewing. Costs rise; set a calendar reminder to review prices at least twice a year.
How to test and raise prices safely
- Test before you commit. Offer two or three packages (good, better, best) and see which customers choose.
- Use pre-sales. Customers who pay in advance prove the price, not just the interest.
- Raise prices for new customers first, then give existing customers notice and a clear reason.
- Watch the numbers: conversion rate, average order value, gross margin and repeat purchases.
Pricing also affects taxes and cash flow. Track your profit by product or service, keep receipts for every cost, and set aside money for taxes from each payment. Our guide to small business tax changes for 2026 explains the current federal rules for freelancers and founders.
What pricing teaches about investing in business assets
The same arithmetic applies to any asset that earns income, whether it is a coffee machine, a delivery van or a truck. Revenue minus variable costs, minus fixed costs such as insurance and maintenance, is what is left for the owner. Understanding that math helps you judge an income-producing investment, including fractional ownership of real assets through Pearset Assets, where payouts depend on how the asset actually performs and are not guaranteed.
Frequently asked questions
What is the easiest pricing method for a new business?
Cost-plus pricing is the easiest: add up all costs per unit, including a share of fixed costs, and add a markup. Use it as your minimum price, then check it against competitor prices and the value customers receive.
What is the difference between markup and margin?
Markup is profit as a percentage of cost; margin is profit as a percentage of price. An item that costs $10 and sells for $15 has a 50% markup but a 33% margin.
When should I use value-based pricing?
Value-based pricing fits services, business-to-business work and specialist or premium products where you can show the customer saves or earns money, time or risk. It needs customer research to back it up.
How do I set an hourly rate as a freelancer?
Add your target annual income, yearly business costs and taxes, then divide by realistic billable hours, which are often only 50% to 70% of hours worked. That gives your minimum rate.
How often should I review my prices?
Review prices at least twice a year and whenever your costs change significantly. Test new prices with new customers first and give existing customers notice.
Sources
All sources were checked on November 9, 2026.
- U.S. Small Business Administration: Plan your business (checked November 9, 2026)
- U.S. Small Business Administration: Manage your business (checked November 9, 2026)